• About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
Wednesday, September 3, 2025
Daily Intel Newspapers
  • Login
  • Welcome
  • Special reports
    • All
    • Unedited for the record
    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

    23,659  persons missing in Nigeria, says Red cross

    23,659 persons missing in Nigeria, says Red cross

    Uzodimma’s minimum increase a landmine for next Imo gov- Observers

    Uzodimma’s minimum increase a landmine for next Imo gov- Observers

    How MKO Abiola’s rift with editors inspired Newswatch magazine — Veteran journalist

    How MKO Abiola’s rift with editors inspired Newswatch magazine — Veteran journalist

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

  • Metro News
    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    FCTA clears 1,000 shanties in Abuja district

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Wike launch operation to flush street beggars, one- chance syndicate, others in FCT

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Teachers, health workers strike,others: Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

  • Latest News
    • All
    • Crime watch
    Tinubu signs Insurance reform bill into law

    Tinubu recalls NTA DG, cancel recent appointments

    NAPTIP receives 12 trafficking victims, arrests accomplice

    NAPTIP receives 12 trafficking victims, arrests accomplice

    Price of UK houses drops in August-Nationwide data

    Price of UK houses drops in August-Nationwide data

    JUST IN: Niger State governor dissolves cabinet

    JUST IN: Niger State governor dissolves cabinet

    BREAKING: FCT loses Head of Service

    BREAKING: FCT loses Head of Service

    SERAP to  Tinubu: Reverse passport fees hike

    SERAP to Tinubu: Reverse passport fees hike

    Trending Tags

  • Infotech
    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Senate approves restoration of Aniocha North II State Constituency, Delta

    Bill mandating social media platforms to have physical office, records of employees pass second reading at the Senate

    Nigeria investigated  213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    Nigeria investigated 213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    MTN denies orchestrating poor network to influence FG, labour talk, apologizes for network fluctuations

    MTN shuns Labour-FG committee on tariff review, hike data tariff by 200%

  • World conflict & diplomacy
    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

  • Security
    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Police, Omatekun, confirms the kidnap of seven farmers in Ondo

    Fear of attack grips Kwara NYSC over suspicious movements around camp

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure  scores in Borno community

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure scores in Borno community

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

No Result
View All Result
  • Welcome
  • Special reports
    • All
    • Unedited for the record
    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

    23,659  persons missing in Nigeria, says Red cross

    23,659 persons missing in Nigeria, says Red cross

    Uzodimma’s minimum increase a landmine for next Imo gov- Observers

    Uzodimma’s minimum increase a landmine for next Imo gov- Observers

    How MKO Abiola’s rift with editors inspired Newswatch magazine — Veteran journalist

    How MKO Abiola’s rift with editors inspired Newswatch magazine — Veteran journalist

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

  • Metro News
    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    FCTA clears 1,000 shanties in Abuja district

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Wike launch operation to flush street beggars, one- chance syndicate, others in FCT

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Teachers, health workers strike,others: Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

  • Latest News
    • All
    • Crime watch
    Tinubu signs Insurance reform bill into law

    Tinubu recalls NTA DG, cancel recent appointments

    NAPTIP receives 12 trafficking victims, arrests accomplice

    NAPTIP receives 12 trafficking victims, arrests accomplice

    Price of UK houses drops in August-Nationwide data

    Price of UK houses drops in August-Nationwide data

    JUST IN: Niger State governor dissolves cabinet

    JUST IN: Niger State governor dissolves cabinet

    BREAKING: FCT loses Head of Service

    BREAKING: FCT loses Head of Service

    SERAP to  Tinubu: Reverse passport fees hike

    SERAP to Tinubu: Reverse passport fees hike

    Trending Tags

  • Infotech
    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Senate approves restoration of Aniocha North II State Constituency, Delta

    Bill mandating social media platforms to have physical office, records of employees pass second reading at the Senate

    Nigeria investigated  213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    Nigeria investigated 213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    MTN denies orchestrating poor network to influence FG, labour talk, apologizes for network fluctuations

    MTN shuns Labour-FG committee on tariff review, hike data tariff by 200%

  • World conflict & diplomacy
    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

  • Security
    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Police, Omatekun, confirms the kidnap of seven farmers in Ondo

    Fear of attack grips Kwara NYSC over suspicious movements around camp

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure  scores in Borno community

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure scores in Borno community

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

No Result
View All Result
Daily Intel Newspapers
No Result
View All Result
Support Us Support Us Support Us
Home Opinion

In Rivers State, a supreme iniquity? | By Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

Daily Intel Newspaper by Daily Intel Newspaper
March 9, 2025
Nigeria’s hostages in law | Opinion by Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

#image_title

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterChat With Us Live

The political control of the resources of the territory known as Rivers State in Nigeria’s Niger Delta has been a site of curious jurisprudence since the Acting Consul of the Oil Rivers Protectorate, Harry Johnston, procured the judicial liquidation of King Jaja of Opobo in December 1887 in Accra, present capital of Ghana. The charge against King Jaja was the violation of a treaty obligation to assist the British “in the execution of such duties as may be assigned.” At the end of proceedings which lasted less than one day before a forum described by Elvar Ingimundarsson as a “Kangaroo court”, King Jaja was convicted and sentenced to exile. The court also prohibited the people of Opobo from designating a replacement for him.

At the end of February 2025, Nigeria’s Supreme Court continued a tradition of afflicting the people of the territory of Rivers State with curious jurisprudence. Separated by 137 years, the decision of the Supreme Court in the latest of the legal disputes from the political rift between incumbent governor, Siminalayi Fubara, and his predecessor, Nyesom Wike, reprises essential parallels with the trial and exile of King Jaja with haunting similarity.

Now, as then, the underlying dispute is really about “a treaty”; in this case allegedly between the governor and his predecessor, the terms of which also appear to be about “the execution of such duties as may be assigned….” The court orders are against a ruling figure (Governor Fubara) from Opobo and the political effect is to seek to exile him from office while precluding any other Opobo person from replacing him.

Context is necessary to understand the case that the Supreme Court had to decide. Going into the 2023 election, the governor of Rivers State, Nyesom Wike, was term-limited. In 2020 and 2021, he publicly declared that he would not impose a successor on the state. In 2023, he did. His choice was a little-known public servant from Opobo-Nkoro, Sim Fubara. After the election, their relationship disintegrated. The reasons are subliminal in this case; the consequences are explicit.

In December 2023, 27 members of the Rivers State House of Assembly loyal to Nyesom Wike, including the Speaker, Martin Amaewhule, ostentatiously announced that they had defected to the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC). In 2015, the Supreme Court of Nigeria ruled that such defection is permissible only if the political party from which the legislators seek to defect is so hopelessly splintered that it “makes it impossible or impracticable for [the] political party to function as such.” If not, according to the court, “the defector automatically looses (sic) his seat.”

With the defection of Martin Amaewhule and his 26 other colleagues, the House of Assembly of Rivers State became factionalised. The remaining five members were loyal to the incumbent governor. Shortly after the defection of the Amaewhule faction in December 2023, the premises of the Rivers State House of Assembly were demolished ostensibly on the orders of the state government. The faction loyal to the state governor relocated to the Government House where, shortly thereafter, they purported to pass into law the 2024 Appropriation Bill for the State, which became law when the governor promptly assented to it.

The outbreak of litigation that followed has been inexhaustible. The appeal determined by a five-person panel of the Supreme Court on 28 February 2025 is one them. Essentially, it sought orders to restrain the Central Bank of Nigeria from remitting to Rivers State, its share of the proceeds from the Federation Account except to finance a budget passed by the Amaewhule faction of the State House of Assembly. In other words, this was litigation asking the judiciary to take sides in what is in fact a very grubby dispute over control of Rivers State’s money.

This case traveled up to the Supreme Court with supreme alacrity. The Federal High Court delivered judgment on 30 October 2024, a mere three and a half months after filing on 15 July. Not wishing to be outdone, the Court of Appeal delivered judgment on 13 December 2024, less than a month and a half later. The Supreme Court has been equally supersonic in bringing the case to judgment.

The Supreme Court dealt with two issues when it should have addressed at least three. First, it affirmed the jurisdiction of the Federal High Court to hear the case. Next, on the question whether the rump of the House of Assembly of Rivers State loyal to the governor could constitutionally sit to pass the 2024 budget, it held that they could not. In support of this position, the court cited precedent applicable to when the legislature sits on impeachment, a special procedure for which the constitutionally prescribed parliamentary arithmetic is different.

The third issue, it left unattended. The Court simply proceeded without deliberation or reasoning to grant all the orders asked for.

An injunction, the principal relief sought in this case, is notoriously a remedy in equity, only granted deliberatively. Over one century ago, the path-breaking decision in The Lusitania laid down the principle that “as a general rule of both civil and common law…. the remedy must be commensurate with the injury received.”

There are four glaring problems with this Supreme Court judgment. The first is not what is in it but what is missing. Lawyers claim that “equity does not act in vain.” The Supreme Court did not bother to provide any reasoning or justification for its orders, leaving it open to legitimate accusations of having acted in vain or in a transaction. Granting the court every latitude on the violations that it found, its orders are an unreasoned overreach.

Second, ordering the Central Bank to withhold Rivers state’s share of the Federation Account is at best a rogue order that punishes the people for a dispute between politicians. It violates the maxim that “equity regards the beneficiary (in this case the people of Rivers State) as the true owner.” Their right to their share of the Federation Account is antecedent to, independent of, and unconnected with the dispute in this case.

Third, being aware of the ongoing litigation on the legal consequences of the defection of the Amaewhule faction of the State House of Assembly, the Supreme Court short-circuited a contingent appellate process and issued dispositions on a dispute that was neither before it nor necessary for the determination of the issues it was called upon to decide. In doing so, the court chose with a touch of injudicious shamelessness to accept the invitation to take sides in the underlying political dispute in Rivers State.

Fourth, the Supreme Court announced revolutionary jurisprudence on the judicial fly, claiming that, in cases where there is a disputed defection, “[o]nly the [legislature] can declare a seat vacant for defection and not the Governor of a State. Not even the Courts can do so.” It takes heedless audacity for an apex court to castrate the judiciary. That is exactly what the court did with this line in italics. When the Supreme Court laid down the contrary principle in 2015, it was by a panel of seven Justices. This Supreme Court purports to overrule that principle without even citing, acknowledging, or considering its earlier decisions on the same point. Moreover, a five-person panel of the Supreme Court cannot overrule a seven-person panel.

When Chief Justice of Nigeria, Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, showed up reportedly to turn the sod on proposed judicial digs with Nyesom Wike last October, there were unheeded warnings then concerning the prohibitive institutional costs of such dalliance with a notorious political litigant who has a reputation for instrumentalizing the courts. Many will look at this recent decision from the Supreme Court and say “we told you so.” For the CJN, it will be argued that she was not on the panel; to which the response will be, she chose the judges and constituted the panel.

On 1 December 1887, the Kangaroo court of Rear Admiral Walter Hunt-Grubbe ruled that the presence of King Jaja in Opobo “would be fatal” to British commercial interests and authorized his eventual exile to West Indies. The judgment was widely seen as a transactional travesty and its effect, it was said, was “to haunt the British colonial administration in West Africa for a long time.” It may similarly be said of what the courts of post-colonial Nigeria did in the 137th year of that iniquity that they sought in another transactional travesty to exile another figure from Opobo from his position because his presence would be fatal to the interests of Nigeria’s most prolific political litigant.

A lawyer and a teacher, Odinkalu can be reached on chidi.odinkalu@tufts.edu

Share188Tweet118SendShare
Support Us Support Us Support Us
Daily Intel Newspaper

Daily Intel Newspaper

Next Post
Kwara: Police confirm killing of Miyetti Allah chairman by gunmen 

Kwara: Police confirm killing of Miyetti Allah chairman by gunmen 

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POPULAR POST

  • CBN directs Moniepoint, others to stop registering new customers

    CBN gives Moniepoint, OPay, others go ahead to onboard new customers

    791 shares
    Share 316 Tweet 198
  • South-East importers, exporters threaten strike over Nigerian Shippers’ Council’s 200% rates hike

    649 shares
    Share 260 Tweet 162
  • BREAKING: President Tinubu approves the reappointment of Adaji as DG of NBC

    634 shares
    Share 254 Tweet 159
  • Nigeria’s foreign reserves records $1.8bn fall in two months

    543 shares
    Share 217 Tweet 136
  • How Imo Chief Judge Theresa Chikeka falsified age, refuse to retire | Opinion by Odinkalu

    532 shares
    Share 213 Tweet 133

STAY CONNECTED

Follow Us

Categories

  • Aviation
  • Business
  • Citizen reporter
  • Corruption
  • Crime watch
  • Culture
  • Document
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Exclusive
  • Featured
  • Finance & economy
  • Foreign News
  • Health
  • Human rights & the people
  • Infotech
  • Interviews
  • Investigation
  • Judiciary
  • Latest News
  • Maritime
  • Metro News
  • News
  • Oil & gas
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Promoted
  • Science & Technology
  • Security
  • Special reports
  • Special updates
  • Sports
  • Unedited for the record
  • World conflict & diplomacy

LATEST NEWS

Tinubu signs Insurance reform bill into law

Tinubu recalls NTA DG, cancel recent appointments

September 2, 2025
Politicians, bow your heads in shame. The giant of Africa has fallen | By Daniel Okonkwo

Politicians, bow your heads in shame. The giant of Africa has fallen | By Daniel Okonkwo

September 2, 2025
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Donate

© 2025 All Rights Reserved Daily Intel Newspapers

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Special reports
  • Special updates
  • World conflict & diplomacy
  • Infotech
  • Metro News
  • Latest News
    • Human rights & the people
    • Unedited for the record
    • Judiciary
  • Finance & economy
  • Exclusive
  • Security
  • Document
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Infotech
  • Investigation
  • Science & Technology
  • Aviation
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Finance & economy
  • Foreign News
  • Health
  • Corruption
  • Promoted
  • Crime watch

© 2025 All Rights Reserved Daily Intel Newspapers

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In