• About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
Wednesday, September 10, 2025
Daily Intel Newspapers
  • Login
  • Welcome
  • Special reports
    • All
    • Unedited for the record
    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    UN strongly condemn Borno attack that claimed 63 lives, including soldiers

    PANDEF back Tinubu’s state police proposal

    PANDEF back Tinubu’s state police proposal

    Canada’s economy sheds over 60,000 jobs in August

    Canada’s economy sheds over 60,000 jobs in August

    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

  • Metro News
    Doctors in FCT commence warning strike, cite systemic failure, infrastructure decay, others

    Doctors in FCT commence warning strike, cite systemic failure, infrastructure decay, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    FCTA clears 1,000 shanties in Abuja district

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Wike launch operation to flush street beggars, one- chance syndicate, others in FCT

  • Latest News
    • All
    • Crime watch
    Nasarawa assembly confirms Wandai as NASIEC chairman

    Nasarawa assembly confirms Wandai as NASIEC chairman

    NIMC warns against extortion, says NIN modification must follow approved guidelines

    NIMC warns against extortion, says NIN modification must follow approved guidelines

    Yobe crime rate down by 70%-Police

    Yobe crime rate down by 70%-Police

    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Ex-petroleum minister advocates raising of NCI fund to $1bn

    Ex-petroleum minister advocates raising of NCI fund to $1bn

    OPEC+ to ramp up oil output in October

    OPEC+ to ramp up oil output in October

    Trending Tags

  • Infotech
    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Senate approves restoration of Aniocha North II State Constituency, Delta

    Bill mandating social media platforms to have physical office, records of employees pass second reading at the Senate

    Nigeria investigated  213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    Nigeria investigated 213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    MTN denies orchestrating poor network to influence FG, labour talk, apologizes for network fluctuations

    MTN shuns Labour-FG committee on tariff review, hike data tariff by 200%

  • World conflict & diplomacy
    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

  • Security
    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Police, Omatekun, confirms the kidnap of seven farmers in Ondo

    Fear of attack grips Kwara NYSC over suspicious movements around camp

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure  scores in Borno community

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure scores in Borno community

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

No Result
View All Result
  • Welcome
  • Special reports
    • All
    • Unedited for the record
    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    UN strongly condemn Borno attack that claimed 63 lives, including soldiers

    PANDEF back Tinubu’s state police proposal

    PANDEF back Tinubu’s state police proposal

    Canada’s economy sheds over 60,000 jobs in August

    Canada’s economy sheds over 60,000 jobs in August

    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    Embrace Igbo identity, Senator Nwoko urges Anioma people

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

    NCDMB outlines achievements,charges media, youth groups on social responsibility

  • Metro News
    Doctors in FCT commence warning strike, cite systemic failure, infrastructure decay, others

    Doctors in FCT commence warning strike, cite systemic failure, infrastructure decay, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    FCTA clears 1,000 shanties in Abuja district

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    FCT set up committee to probe sales of FG houses, parks

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Wike launch operation to flush street beggars, one- chance syndicate, others in FCT

  • Latest News
    • All
    • Crime watch
    Nasarawa assembly confirms Wandai as NASIEC chairman

    Nasarawa assembly confirms Wandai as NASIEC chairman

    NIMC warns against extortion, says NIN modification must follow approved guidelines

    NIMC warns against extortion, says NIN modification must follow approved guidelines

    Yobe crime rate down by 70%-Police

    Yobe crime rate down by 70%-Police

    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Nepal lifts social media ban after deadly protest

    Ex-petroleum minister advocates raising of NCI fund to $1bn

    Ex-petroleum minister advocates raising of NCI fund to $1bn

    OPEC+ to ramp up oil output in October

    OPEC+ to ramp up oil output in October

    Trending Tags

  • Infotech
    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    NIMC partners online publishers to boost digital security through NIN enrollment

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Senate approves restoration of Aniocha North II State Constituency, Delta

    Bill mandating social media platforms to have physical office, records of employees pass second reading at the Senate

    Nigeria investigated  213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    Nigeria investigated 213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    MTN denies orchestrating poor network to influence FG, labour talk, apologizes for network fluctuations

    MTN shuns Labour-FG committee on tariff review, hike data tariff by 200%

  • World conflict & diplomacy
    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Hamas accepts new Gaza truce plan – Official

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Ukraine conflict: Trump and Putin end Alaska summit without deal

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Rwanda-backed rebels kill hundreds in DRC despite U.S.-sanctioned ceasefire

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    Sudan claims army destroys Emirati aircraft, killing Colombian mercenaries

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

  • Security
    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Fight against insurgency: Middle-belt Forum hail FG, Israel security pact

    Police, Omatekun, confirms the kidnap of seven farmers in Ondo

    Fear of attack grips Kwara NYSC over suspicious movements around camp

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure  scores in Borno community

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure scores in Borno community

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

No Result
View All Result
Daily Intel Newspapers
No Result
View All Result
Support Us Support Us Support Us
Home Opinion

By criminalising civil dispute, Dele Farotimi becomes a victim of misused instruments of the State | Opinion by Chidi Odinkalu

Daily Intel Newspaper by Daily Intel Newspaper
December 8, 2024
By criminalising civil dispute, Dele Farotimi becomes a victim of misused instruments of the State | Opinion by Chidi Odinkalu

#image_title

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterChat With Us Live

Paul Anyebe was a judge of the High Court of Benue State in north-central Nigeria who had a young son with sticky fingers and a sense of adventure. It was his role as a dad that endangered his job as a judge.

One night around 1983, Anyebe caught his son attempting to steal from his bedroom. In response, Anyebe pulled his gun in an effort to scare the boy. The gun went off, discharging a bullet which hit and seriously injured the boy. The Attorney-General of Benue State decided to prosecute Paul Anyebe for attempted murder. The Penal Code applicable in Benue State at the time had ample provisions for the crime of attempted murder. 

The Attorney-General also added a charge of illegal possession of firearms, a federal offence. Unlike the crime of attempted murder, which was a state crime in Benue State, all firearms offences are federal. The Attorney-General of Benue was well within his powers to prosecute for attempted murder but only the Attorney-General of the Federation could prosecute or authorise prosecution for federal offences. 

At the conclusion of the trial, the High Court of Benue State discharged Paul Anyebe on the charge of attempted murder, a state offence, but convicted him on the charge of illegal possession of firearms (a federal offence), for which it sentenced him to three years in prison. The Court of Appeal reduced this sentence to six months in prison or a fine of one hundred naira. Following this decision, and while his appeal was yet to be heard by the Supreme Court, Paul Anyebe was dismissed as a judge. 

When the Supreme Court decided Anyebe’s appeal in January 1986, Dahunsi Olugbemi Coker, a justice of the court, summed up the issue for decision in one sentence: “The short point is whether a State Attorney-General can prosecute an offence created by an Act of the National Assembly.” To this question, the court unanimously responded in the negative. They nullified Anyebe’s trial and ordered the fine paid – one hundred naira – refunded to him. The Court of Appeal ordered his reinstatement with full benefits.

Adolphus Godwin Karibi-Whyte, one of the justices who decided Anyebe’s appeal at the Supreme Court, said the case decided that ”the Attorney-General of a State has no general authority to exercise the powers of the Attorney-General of the Federation to prosecute in respect of federal offences.”

One effect of this decision is to preclude the prosecution of federal crimes before state courts. A Magistrates Court is a state court. It does not have jurisdiction over federal crimes.

Thirty-eight years after the Supreme Court of Nigeria established this principle in Anyebe’s case, the Nigeria Police Force (NPF)on December 4 arraigned lawyer and writer, Dele Farotimi, before a magistrate in Ekiti State on 16 counts of crimes under the Criminal Code Act, a federal legislation.

Three years ago, Ekiti State enacted into law the Criminal Law of Ekiti State, no. 12 of 2021, which repealed and replaced the state’s pre-existing Criminal Code Law of 2012. Comprising nine parts, 429 sections and 140 pages, Ekiti State’s Criminal Law of 2021 does not include the crime of criminal libel or defamation. Section 70 of the law contains a crime of causing disaffection or breach of the peace through offensive publication but that is a simple offence punishable by six months in prison. It is not in issue in this case. 

Last week, on December 3, operatives of the NPF heisted Dele Farotimi from his residence in Lagos State, where the crime of criminal defamation is similarly unknown to law. They raced him across state lines to Ekiti where they detained him. The following morning, on December 4, the police arraigned Dele before a magistrate in the state capital. 

This is important because the gist of the charges purportedly preferred against Dele Farotimi before the magistrate in Ekiti is precisely criminal defamation, which is not a crime in Ekiti State.

It seemed quite clear that the charges presented by the police did not disclose a crime known to the laws of Ekiti State, nor did they disclose a crime over which a magistrate in Ekiti State could purport to exercise lawful jurisdiction. Despite the evident absence of jurisdiction on multiple fronts, the Magistrate proceeded with undue haste to order the remand of Dele Farotimi in prison custody for one week until December 10. The magistrate probably did not realise that December 10 is International Human Rights Day.

Even if the magistrate had jurisdiction, which he did not, the crime alleged was punishable with two years in prison. Under section 4(5) of the Criminal Law of Ekiti State, this is classed as a “misdemeanour” at best, that is to say, “an offence punishable by imprisonment for not less than six months, but less than three years.” These are bailable on liberal terms. Offences punishable by more than three years in prison are called “felonies”. Those are regarded as serious offences. The order of remand in this case seemed wilful with a whiff of the pre-determined about it. 

The United Nations Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power has a name for what happens when a court orders prison remand for a crime which does not exist in law and in proceedings over which it lacks powers. It is called “criminal abuse of power.”

Many people claiming to be senior lawyers have invited Dele Farotimi to have his day in court, where he can prove the allegations the subject of these charges or face the consequences. This is designed to make all this seem like an invocation of law. It isn’t.

First, Dele Farotimi can only do so before a court of competent jurisdiction. A magistrate claiming to sit over a crime that does not exist in the state is not such a court. 

Second, the burden in criminal proceedings is on the state to prove that the accused guilty. So, criminal proceedings in Ekiti or anywhere cannot possibly be the forum for Dele Farotimito prove the truth of his claims. Anyone who makes that assertion is either wilfully jejune or must concede that the only opportunity to put that to test has to be in civil proceedings.

Third, insisting on the kind of proceedings now going on in Ekiti state without any sense of irony only reinforces the kinds of claims that Dele Farotimi makes in his best-selling book about supposedly legal and judicial processes which seem to occur in the pockets of human principalities given to playing god. A lot of things may yet happen in those kinds of proceedings but it does not look like law will be one of them. 

Moreover, in 2021, the Supreme Court of Nigeria – no less –  condemned as “vexatious and oppressive” and “dangerously rampant”, the “misuse of the criminal law machinery for getting reliefs in disputes that are civil in nature, by using the instruments of State.” The court also required that “a complainant who initiates a prosecution with the knowledge that criminal proceedings are unwarranted and the remedy lies in the civil law, should be made accountable in law for pursuing misconceived criminal proceedings.”

In that same case in 2021, the Supreme Court described the crime of criminal defamation as “an innovation in Star Chamber”,a reference to a notoriously arbitrary and captured judicial forum dating back to late mediaeval England. It was not ajudicial endearment. 

Dele Farotimi himself was perspicacious about the events as they have so far unfolded. Shortly before he was taken from Lagos, he warned: “abducting me to be tried in Ekiti State is not justice but a witch-hunt.”

Somewhere in Ekiti State on International Human Rights Day 2024, the very rights consecrated by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights will face the guillotine with Dele Farotimi strung up as the sacrifice. Those who think this vindication may yet live to rue their affliction with terminal hubris.

A lawyer and a teacher, Odinkalu can be reached at chidi.odinkalu@tufts.edu

Share195Tweet122SendShare
Support Us Support Us Support Us
Daily Intel Newspaper

Daily Intel Newspaper

Next Post
Cross River Magistrates announces indefinite strike over unmet demands

Cross River Magistrates announces indefinite strike over unmet demands

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POPULAR POST

  • CBN directs Moniepoint, others to stop registering new customers

    CBN gives Moniepoint, OPay, others go ahead to onboard new customers

    791 shares
    Share 316 Tweet 198
  • South-East importers, exporters threaten strike over Nigerian Shippers’ Council’s 200% rates hike

    649 shares
    Share 260 Tweet 162
  • BREAKING: President Tinubu approves the reappointment of Adaji as DG of NBC

    634 shares
    Share 254 Tweet 159
  • Nigeria’s foreign reserves records $1.8bn fall in two months

    543 shares
    Share 217 Tweet 136
  • How Imo Chief Judge Theresa Chikeka falsified age, refuse to retire | Opinion by Odinkalu

    532 shares
    Share 213 Tweet 133

STAY CONNECTED

Follow Us

Categories

  • Aviation
  • Business
  • Citizen reporter
  • Corruption
  • Crime watch
  • Culture
  • Document
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Exclusive
  • Featured
  • Finance & economy
  • Foreign News
  • Health
  • Human rights & the people
  • Infotech
  • Interviews
  • Investigation
  • Judiciary
  • Latest News
  • Maritime
  • Metro News
  • News
  • Oil & gas
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Promoted
  • Science & Technology
  • Security
  • Special reports
  • Special updates
  • Sports
  • Unedited for the record
  • World conflict & diplomacy

LATEST NEWS

Nasarawa assembly confirms Wandai as NASIEC chairman

Nasarawa assembly confirms Wandai as NASIEC chairman

September 9, 2025
NIMC warns against extortion, says NIN modification must follow approved guidelines

NIMC warns against extortion, says NIN modification must follow approved guidelines

September 9, 2025
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Donate

© 2025 All Rights Reserved Daily Intel Newspapers

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Special reports
  • Special updates
  • World conflict & diplomacy
  • Infotech
  • Metro News
  • Latest News
    • Human rights & the people
    • Unedited for the record
    • Judiciary
  • Finance & economy
  • Exclusive
  • Security
  • Document
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Infotech
  • Investigation
  • Science & Technology
  • Aviation
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Finance & economy
  • Foreign News
  • Health
  • Corruption
  • Promoted
  • Crime watch

© 2025 All Rights Reserved Daily Intel Newspapers

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In