• About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
Tuesday, July 15, 2025
Daily Intel Newspapers
  • Login
  • Welcome
  • Special reports
    • All
    • Unedited for the record
    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Group alleges corruption, nepotism, others, calls for immediate sack of NMDPRA Boss

    Group alleges corruption, nepotism, others, calls for immediate sack of NMDPRA Boss

    SNAPSHOTS OF ACHIEVEMENTS

    Ohanaeze renews clamour for IPOB leader, Nnamdi Kanu’s release

    IPOB calls for review, says Kanya court ruling confirms Kanu’s trial lack legal foundation

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Ohanaeze renews clamour for IPOB leader, Nnamdi Kanu’s release

    Ohanaeze renews clamour for IPOB leader, Nnamdi Kanu’s release

  • Metro News
    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Wike launch operation to flush street beggars, one- chance syndicate, others in FCT

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Teachers, health workers strike,others: Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Abuja braces for two-week without water as rehabilitation works commence

    Abuja braces for two-week without water as rehabilitation works commence

    Ground rent: FCTA to take ownership of 4,794 revoked properties from Monday

    Ground rent: FCTA to take ownership of 4,794 revoked properties from Monday

  • Latest News
    • All
    • Crime watch
    Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

    Ex-president Buhari’s body departs London

    Ogun workers begin indefinite strike over non-remittance of pension, others

    Ogun workers begin indefinite strike over non-remittance of pension, others

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Police confirms crash of Netherland bound London plane

    UPDATE: Four people killed in London plane crash-Report

    Police confirms crash of Netherland bound London plane

    Police confirms crash of Netherland bound London plane

    Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

    Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

    Trending Tags

  • Infotech
    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Senate approves restoration of Aniocha North II State Constituency, Delta

    Bill mandating social media platforms to have physical office, records of employees pass second reading at the Senate

    Nigeria investigated  213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    Nigeria investigated 213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    MTN denies orchestrating poor network to influence FG, labour talk, apologizes for network fluctuations

    MTN shuns Labour-FG committee on tariff review, hike data tariff by 200%

    Disconnections not to frustrate ₦EndBadGovernance Protest-Telcos

    FG receives recommendation on telecoms tarrif hike

  • World conflict & diplomacy
    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Iran slams G7 statement for ignoring Israel’s blatant aggression

    Iran slams G7 statement for ignoring Israel’s blatant aggression

    Iran launch over 100 drones towards Israel as conflict escalates

    Iran launch over 100 drones towards Israel as conflict escalates

    Six nuclear scientists killed in Israel attack on Iran — Reports

    Six nuclear scientists killed in Israel attack on Iran — Reports

    UK backs Morocco’s autonomy plan for Western Sahara

    UK backs Morocco’s autonomy plan for Western Sahara

  • Security
    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure  scores in Borno community

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure scores in Borno community

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Police extend deadline for tinted glass permit to August 12

    Police extend deadline for tinted glass permit to August 12

    Tinubu govt assures farmers of security support against bandits, killer herdsmen

    Tinubu govt assures farmers of security support against bandits, killer herdsmen

No Result
View All Result
  • Welcome
  • Special reports
    • All
    • Unedited for the record
    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Group alleges corruption, nepotism, others, calls for immediate sack of NMDPRA Boss

    Group alleges corruption, nepotism, others, calls for immediate sack of NMDPRA Boss

    SNAPSHOTS OF ACHIEVEMENTS

    Ohanaeze renews clamour for IPOB leader, Nnamdi Kanu’s release

    IPOB calls for review, says Kanya court ruling confirms Kanu’s trial lack legal foundation

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Ohanaeze renews clamour for IPOB leader, Nnamdi Kanu’s release

    Ohanaeze renews clamour for IPOB leader, Nnamdi Kanu’s release

  • Metro News
    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Imo government move to end open grazing in Owerri, issues two-week ultimatum to herders

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Lagos Assembly move to enact law to regulate house rents, agents, others

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Wike launch operation to flush street beggars, one- chance syndicate, others in FCT

    Teachers, health workers strike,others:  Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Teachers, health workers strike,others: Wike gets fresh ultimatum from FCT workers

    Abuja braces for two-week without water as rehabilitation works commence

    Abuja braces for two-week without water as rehabilitation works commence

    Ground rent: FCTA to take ownership of 4,794 revoked properties from Monday

    Ground rent: FCTA to take ownership of 4,794 revoked properties from Monday

  • Latest News
    • All
    • Crime watch
    Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

    Ex-president Buhari’s body departs London

    Ogun workers begin indefinite strike over non-remittance of pension, others

    Ogun workers begin indefinite strike over non-remittance of pension, others

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Police confirms crash of Netherland bound London plane

    UPDATE: Four people killed in London plane crash-Report

    Police confirms crash of Netherland bound London plane

    Police confirms crash of Netherland bound London plane

    Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

    Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

    Trending Tags

  • Infotech
    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Facebook set new monetization rules for creators who uses other people content

    Senate approves restoration of Aniocha North II State Constituency, Delta

    Bill mandating social media platforms to have physical office, records of employees pass second reading at the Senate

    Nigeria investigated  213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    Nigeria investigated 213 privacy breaches in 2024-NDPC

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    FG begins construction of emerging technologies Institute in Kano

    MTN denies orchestrating poor network to influence FG, labour talk, apologizes for network fluctuations

    MTN shuns Labour-FG committee on tariff review, hike data tariff by 200%

    Disconnections not to frustrate ₦EndBadGovernance Protest-Telcos

    FG receives recommendation on telecoms tarrif hike

  • World conflict & diplomacy
    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    UK prime minister back US military strikes on Iran ‘s nuclear sites

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Israel bombs Iran’s heavy water reactor, says state television

    Iran slams G7 statement for ignoring Israel’s blatant aggression

    Iran slams G7 statement for ignoring Israel’s blatant aggression

    Iran launch over 100 drones towards Israel as conflict escalates

    Iran launch over 100 drones towards Israel as conflict escalates

    Six nuclear scientists killed in Israel attack on Iran — Reports

    Six nuclear scientists killed in Israel attack on Iran — Reports

    UK backs Morocco’s autonomy plan for Western Sahara

    UK backs Morocco’s autonomy plan for Western Sahara

  • Security
    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    Nwifuru demands arrest of killers of 13 Ebonyi indigenes in Anambra

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    State police only solution to Benue killings, others- Adams

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure  scores in Borno community

    Female suicide bomber kills 24, injure scores in Borno community

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Obi calls for immediate end to violence against Benue communities

    Police extend deadline for tinted glass permit to August 12

    Police extend deadline for tinted glass permit to August 12

    Tinubu govt assures farmers of security support against bandits, killer herdsmen

    Tinubu govt assures farmers of security support against bandits, killer herdsmen

No Result
View All Result
Daily Intel Newspapers
No Result
View All Result
Support Us Support Us Support Us
Home Opinion

How two Josephs gave Nigeria a crisis of Jumpy Judges | Opinion by Chidi Odinkalu

Daily Intel Newspaper by Daily Intel Newspaper
November 10, 2024
Opinion by Chidi Anselm Odinkalu | Nigeria’s Federal High Court: A scandalised court

#image_title

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterChat With Us Live

The unravelling of the regime of General Yakubu Gowon shortly after the end of Nigeria’s civil war in the decade of the 1970s began as a tale of two Josephs. One was Joseph Dechi Gomwalk, Gowon’s in-law and governor of his home state. The other was Joseph Sarwuan Tarka, one of Gowon’s trusted ministers. It made for a riveting political spectacle whose legacies have proved durable. 

In 1974, General Gowon, who had led Nigeria through a 30-month-long civil war, was into his eighth year as military head of state. It was four years after the end of the civil war and the country comprised 12 states. Although he grew up in Zaria, Gowon was Angas, a minority ethnicity in what was then known as Benue-Plateau State, whose military governor was police commissioner Joseph Gomwalk. He was also related to Gowon by marriage. 

Seven months into the year, in July 1974, Godwin Daboh-Adzuana, an activist – or so it was thought then – published an affidavit containing serious allegations of grand corruption against his kinsman and Gowon’s commissioner (minister) of transport and Communication, Joseph Tarka.

Under pressure from Gowon and the public, a reluctant Tarka was forced to resign from his ministerial perch but not before warning that his resignation would “set off a chain of reactions.” At the time, the suspicion was widespread that Godwin Daboh was an agent of the government of Benue-Plateau State.

The following month, at the end of August 1974, Tarka’s protégé, Aper Aku, published his own affidavit containing even more damning allegations, this time against the state governor, Joseph Gomwalk. Atanda Fatayi Williams, at the time a senior Justice of the Supreme Court who would later himself rise to head the country’s judiciary, reports that a troubled Gowon telephoned the Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN) “complaining about how the courts in the country were being used for the indiscriminate swearing of affidavits in which allegations of corruption were made against public functionaries.”

At the time, Taslim Olawale Elias, who had served Gowon as Attorney-General of the Federation for the first six years of his regime, was the CJN—in response to General Gowon’s importuning, Chief Justice Elias embarked on a series of urgent consultations first with the justices of the Supreme Court, followed by an emergency convening of the Advisory Judicial Committee (AJC), the forerunner of what is today known as the National Judicial Council (NJC). At the end of those consultations, the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court issued a press release prohibiting courts generally from allowing any aggrieved persons to depose to affidavits.

Unlike Joseph Tarka, Joseph Gomwalk survived the allegations against him with the help of a judicial landing invented out of nothing by a CJN beholden to the head of state. The AJC lacked the powers to prohibit affidavits but the high command of the judiciary felt obliged genuflect to the head of state. The public uproar was deafening and helped to tar the regime of General Gowon with an eternal brush of corruption. One year later, his colleagues in the military replaced him with his Barewa College junior, Murtala Mohammed. As head of state, Murtala Mohammed disembarked Taslim Elias from the office of CJN. 

This past week called to mind the legacies of those tumultuous embers of the Gowon years and their damaging imprint on the institutional psychology of Nigeria’s judiciary. Last August, the government orchestrated the mass arrest of young people from different parts of northern Nigeria for taking part in the #EndBadGovernance protests. They thereafter transported those young persons to Abuja where they were held for 93 days in pre-trial detention. At their arraignment at the beginning of the month on bogus charges of treason, Obiora Egwuatu, a judge of the Federal High Court in Abuja, granted them bail in the sum of N10 million Naira with two sureties both of whom must be senior, director-level federal civil servants. 

“Egwuatu” in Igbo language could mean “fearless” or “fearful” depending on the tonal infection. In this case, it is not difficult to divine which of these two meanings best captures the state of mind of the judge when he set out to impose bail terms that he surely knew were beyond the reach of the suspects. 

After setting these impossible conditions, the judge adjourned the case to 25 January 2025. The intention was transparent. In response to the spectacle of several of the suspects collapsing in court, the Inspector-General of Police authorized a statement to go out in his name justifying the proceedings and claiming that the collapse of the children in court had been “staged”. Despite the record on the face of the charge sheet indicating clearly that many of the arraigned suspects were children, the prosecutor, Rimazonte Ezekiel, a Superintendent of Police, claimed that they were all adults and that many of them were indeed married with children. 

The public uproar threatened such steep political costs that a regime whose authoritarian instincts had caused the mass arrest and incarceration of the children in the first place nearly lost its nerves. Things moved very quickly. Overnight, the Attorney-General of the Federation asked for and received the transfer of the case file from the Nigeria Police. On the next working day following the weekend, the president reportedly “ordered the release” of the suspects even though they were held under a remand order issued by a court. It was unlikely that the president was exercising powers of the prerogative of mercy under the Constitution because that is contingent on consultation with the National Council of State, which had not convened.

What happened next was even more exciting. The judge with the ambivalent surname who could not previously find a date earlier than the time it takes to trek from Siberia to Ulaanbaatar in the Winter, suddenly discovered an excess supply of free time on his diary. With military alacrity, he held a hearing and ordered the release of all the suspects. 

It was impossible not to see that this case did not involve any application of law. Rather, it was a straightforward case of a judge obeying the president’s instructions. As far as the judicial role in Nigeria goes, a more squalid advertisement of all that is presently wrong with it is difficult to find.

In the aftermath, it was reported that the president had ordered an investigation into what transpired. The NJC may investigate the judge for bringing his office into manifest disrepute but no one should hold their breath. He was following the example of his supine superiors. The Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) is not in a position to investigate its members who were happy to mouth verifiable falsehood in bib and collar. The Body of Benchers, which long ago expropriated this role from the NBA, counts the regime’s poster boy for hubristic impunity, Nyesom Wike, among its leading members. It won’t. The only person who can investigate the Inspector-General of Police, meanwhile, is the president who himself is the author of this whole thing. 

The president’s inquiry does not need to labour too much before reporting. A regime committed to capturing all levers of power and arresting the machinery of constitutional guardrails has succeeded beyond its wildest imagining, enabled – it must be acknowledged – by a complicit judiciary no longer troubled by any inkling of its constitutional obligations. It is the latest illustration of how the story that began as a tale of two Josephs ended up normalising a reign of jumpy judges.

A lawyer and a teacher, Odinkalu can be reached at chidi.odinkalu@tufts.edu

Share186Tweet117SendShare
Support Us Support Us Support Us
Daily Intel Newspaper

Daily Intel Newspaper

Next Post
Biden to meet Trump at White House on Wednesday

Biden to meet Trump at White House on Wednesday

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POPULAR POST

  • CBN directs Moniepoint, others to stop registering new customers

    CBN gives Moniepoint, OPay, others go ahead to onboard new customers

    789 shares
    Share 316 Tweet 197
  • South-East importers, exporters threaten strike over Nigerian Shippers’ Council’s 200% rates hike

    649 shares
    Share 260 Tweet 162
  • BREAKING: President Tinubu approves the reappointment of Adaji as DG of NBC

    633 shares
    Share 253 Tweet 158
  • Nigeria’s foreign reserves records $1.8bn fall in two months

    543 shares
    Share 217 Tweet 136
  • How Imo Chief Judge Theresa Chikeka falsified age, refuse to retire | Opinion by Odinkalu

    532 shares
    Share 213 Tweet 133

STAY CONNECTED

Follow Us

Categories

  • Aviation
  • Business
  • Citizen reporter
  • Corruption
  • Crime watch
  • Culture
  • Document
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Exclusive
  • Featured
  • Finance & economy
  • Foreign News
  • Health
  • Human rights & the people
  • Infotech
  • Interviews
  • Investigation
  • Judiciary
  • Latest News
  • Maritime
  • Metro News
  • News
  • Oil & gas
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Promoted
  • Science & Technology
  • Security
  • Special reports
  • Special updates
  • Sports
  • Unedited for the record
  • World conflict & diplomacy

LATEST NEWS

Ex-Nigeria President Muhammadu Buhari is dead.

Ex-president Buhari’s body departs London

July 15, 2025
Ogun workers begin indefinite strike over non-remittance of pension, others

Ogun workers begin indefinite strike over non-remittance of pension, others

July 15, 2025
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Donate

© 2025 All Rights Reserved Daily Intel Newspapers

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Special reports
  • Special updates
  • World conflict & diplomacy
  • Infotech
  • Metro News
  • Latest News
    • Human rights & the people
    • Unedited for the record
    • Judiciary
  • Finance & economy
  • Exclusive
  • Security
  • Document
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Infotech
  • Investigation
  • Science & Technology
  • Aviation
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Finance & economy
  • Foreign News
  • Health
  • Corruption
  • Promoted
  • Crime watch

© 2025 All Rights Reserved Daily Intel Newspapers

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In